Beyond “Human in the Loop”

Several particapants sitting around a large conference table

ACONA side event co-organized by Sascha Hach and Timothée Hillier-Davis

Together with the UN missions of Austria, Mexico, and Indonesia, PRIF hosted an ACONA side event at UN head­quarters in New York on May 6 as part of the NPT Review Conference. The panel discussion “Beyond ‘Human in the Loop’” addressed how AI develop­ments intersect with existing Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) commit­ments and what policy proposals are now needed to reduce emerging risks. PRIF Researchers Sascha Hach, ACONA Mana­ging Director, and Timothée Hillier-Davis planned and co-organized the event. 

Since AI-nuclear discussions are still focused on AI and NC3 systems, the technology’s potential for dis­armament verification is over­looked. The event therefore aimed to foster a shared under­standing of AI-related nuclear risks, to provide an overview of the potential benefits of AI applications relevant to both nuclear-weapon states and non-nuclear-weapon states and to examine how AI develop­ments inter­sect with, and may affect, existing NPT commitments. 

The panel featured Alice Saltini (ACONA Fellow '26 & Senior Research Lead, RISD), Vladislav Chernavskikh (Researcher, Weapons of Mass Destruc­tions Programme, SIPRI), Alonso Martínez Ruiz (Advisor on Disarmament Affairs, Permanent Represen­tation of Mexico to the UN) and Mallory Stewart (Chief Executive Officer, Council on Strategic Risks). They discussed implications of the UN General Assembly Resolution 80/23 and weighed risks and opportunities of the AI-nuclear nexus for the NPT’s disarmament pillar. As Saltini emphasized, AI should not be viewed merely as a risk multiplier: by speeding up decision-making and potentially increasing reliance on nuclear weapons, it could undermine disarmament – but it could also support it through advances in verification and monitoring.

Regarding options for state parties to strengthen the NPT review process, the parti­cipants assessed paths for enhanced co­operation and identified practical and construc­tive ways to engage with issues within the NPT frame­work. In a first step, the AI-nuclear discussion must therefore be firmly anchored in the realm of disarmament, without neglecting the opportunities for verification, confidence-building, and transparency.

The Arms Control Negotiation Academy ACONA is an inter­national consor­tium led by Höfði Rey­kjavík Peace Centre at the Uni­versity of Iceland, in colla­boration with the Wood­row Wilson Center's History and Pub­lic Policy Pro­gram, Peace Research Insti­tute Frankfurt (PRIF), the Project on Mana­ging the Atom (MTA) at the Belfer Center for Science and Inter­national Affairs at Har­vard Kennedy School, the James Martin Center for Non­proliferation Studies (CNS), and the Davis Center for Russian and Eurasian Studies at Har­vard Uni­versity. At PRIF, the project is led by Christopher Daase and Sascha Hach.