Dissertation on the Impact of Citizen Dialogues on Security Policy on Political Trust

From left to right: Greta Wagner, Nicole Deitelhoff, Sarah Brockmeier-Large, Christopher Daase, Tobias Wille

Sarah Brockmeier-Large has successfully defended her dissertation

On November 11, 2026, Sarah Brockmeier-Large, success­fully de­fended her disser­tation “Debating a ‘World out of Joint’: The Impact of the German Foreign Office’s Citizen Dialogues on Germany’s National Security Strategy on Participants’ and Non-Participants’ Political Attitudes”. Sarah Brockmeier-Large was a doc­toral re­searcher within the Research Initiative ConTrust – Trust in Conflict at PRIF and Goethe University Frank­furt. Nicole Deitelhoff super­vised her disser­tation.

The disser­tation investigates the effects of citizen dia­logues on foreign and security policy on participants’ and non-participants’ political trust and other political attitudes. It examines the German Foreign Office’s citizen dialogues on Germany’s first National Security Strategy. The study tests pre-registered hypo­theses with a pre-/post-test survey using two control groups, qualitative inter­views, a one-year follow-up survey and a survey ex­periment.

The findings reveal a strong selection effect: participants already had markedly higher political trust than the general population. The dialogues did not change their trust, but in the short term they increased participants’ ex­ternal political efficacy. Non-participants who learned about the dialogues showed greater political support for the develop­ment of the National Security Structure, but not more trust. The results suggest that demonstrating govern­ment open­ness through citizen dialogues alone is not enough to build political trust. For future democratic innovations, foreign policy­makers should avoid con­flicting goals, make clear how citizens’ input will shape policy and focus on issues close to citizens’ lives. To better under­stand public opinion, foreign policy­makers could invest more in public opinion polling and focus groups. Overall, Sarah Brockmeier-Large concludes that to better assess the impact of demo­cratic inno­vations and to im­prove foreign policy­makers’ engage­ment of the public, re­searchers and policy­makers should increase collaboration to enable more studies on “real-world” cases such as the one examined in the disser­tation.

After the completion of her disser­tation, Sarah Brockmeier-Large continues to serve as Head of PRIF’s Berlin Office. 

We con­gratulate Sarah on her success­ful disser­tation!